Jump to content

CPL new teams speculation


Recommended Posts

3 hours ago, Initial B said:

I assumed when the CPL talks of instituting pro-rel at 16 teams, they would split those 16 teams. So are you saying they would institute pro-rel with the teams following? Who would those handful of new teams play against for the first few years? Div 2 supporters would probably get bored facing off against the same teams 6-7 times per season. 

If an even split is so unappealing to you, then how would you split so there are enough teams in Div 2? You can't have a 10-team Div 1 and a 6-team Div 2. The only other option I can see would be to focus on building up Div 3 to a CHL-style structure with L1O, PLSQ, and western counterpart, then groom some of those teams to be ready for the jump to a regional Div 2. After some suitable preparation time,  relegate some of the clubs from Div 1 and promote the groomed Div 3 teams to make an initial Div 2. 

Why not use existing lower divisions as a regional series of div 2s?

In other words, you could have a 16 club Div 1 as has been discussed, and at that point (probably ten years from now) treat L1O, the Quebec League, and some similarly situated Western league together as Div 2. The winners of each face off in some kind of playoff, and the absolute D2 champion gets a playoff game against the lowest placed club in the CPL. That would be dramatic and entertaining as hell. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Dominic94 said:

Can the league handle 3 expansion teams in the league 2 years though ? Like talent wise that’s 18 Canadians... 9 of them can be U-21 so I guess that’s easy.  But those are also minimums. Hopefully the caliber is actually high than USL.

Yes easily. There could have been 10 teams to start this year but Ottawa went mental and a couple of other bids didn't come together in time.

I could see Montreal and/or Quebec and one other team (Saskatoon?) enter for 2020. Ottawa and one other team (Surrey?) could be aboard in 2021.  Easily anywhere from 3-5 teams in two years.
 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Initial B said:

they would split those 16 teams. So are you saying they would institute pro-rel with the teams following? 

Yes

4 hours ago, Initial B said:

Who would those handful of new teams play against for the first few years? Div 2 supporters would probably get bored facing off against the same teams 6-7 times per season. 

The timing is important here. 2026 is the world cup and logically launching such league right after is the best timing. Soccer will be at its highest level by then. You're thinking in terms of today...no one disagree that a D2 pre 2026 would work.

Also, there's really no rush. CPL can just carry one until they get enough bids to launch a proper 8 team league.

How do you know the supporters would get bored? They would be playing in both Canadian Championship and fighting for promotion. Places like Kingston or Sherbrooke would surely take that over nothing...

4 hours ago, Initial B said:

If an even split is so unappealing to you, then how would you split so there are enough teams in Div 2?

No splits. CPL could just announce its intend to launch the 2nd tier and now accepting bids.

4 hours ago, Initial B said:

You can't have a 10-team Div 1 and a 6-team Div 2. The only other option I can see would be to focus on building up Div 3 to a CHL-style structure with L1O, PLSQ, and western counterpart, then groom some of those teams to be ready for the jump to a regional Div 2. After some suitable preparation time,  relegate some of the clubs from Div 1 and promote the groomed Div 3 teams to make an initial Div 2. 

It's entirely possible that some D3 teams could upgrade to D2 by finding new investors to fund infrastructure and pay for the higher costs...sure.

I just don't get this split idea of yours. Nowhere did the league ever expressed wanting to do that. They believe they can grow to 16 and then launch a D2. I don't see that being unrealistic after the world cup.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Dominic94 said:

Can the league handle 3 expansion teams in the league 2 years though ? Like talent wise that’s 18 Canadians... 9 of them can be U-21 so I guess that’s easy.  But those are also minimums. Hopefully the caliber is actually high than USL.

Given there are about 90 Canadian players playing pro in USSF sanctioned leagues and more playing overseas, it is not the cream of the crop that are being signed by CanPL teams. Since a lot of the recruiting appears to be reasonably local, there are probably a lot of players of a comparable standard in cities like Montreal and Vancouver that have been steering clear because there is no team local to them at the moment. If this level of soccer can sustain high enough crowds, putting a few more teams together shouldn't be all that challenging in lower mainland BC and the Windsor-Quebec corridor. What might be more problematic is the smaller more remote markets that need to draw players in from elsewhere in Canada, if there start to be too many of them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Dominic94 said:

Can the league handle 3 expansion teams in the league 2 years though ? Like talent wise that’s 18 Canadians... 9 of them can be U-21 so I guess that’s easy.  But those are also minimums. Hopefully the caliber is actually high than USL.

Like BBTB says, we arent even really dipping into the market of CDN playing in NA and overseas.  If the league proves itself and stays afloat after 1 year, you'll see some more migration as some worries about the league will be put to rest.  And hopefully guys like Aleman, Dover, Gee, Mcleod, Didic (USL types) will help fill out any expansion teams.  ANd if there is a little more money for wages in year 2 we should see some sort of uptick in quality on the field.  Either by attracting the better CDN players still out there or paying for better imports.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Also, there will still be the "wait and see" approach for a lot of oversea guys and those in USSF leagues like BBTB said, who Inthink want to see CPL having 1 or 2 seasons under it's belt before switching.

It's undeniable that the CONCACAF league berth attached to the trophy is a major plus, especially when we'll be watching CPL for the 1st time playing in the tournament.

The more CPL can line up successful seasons and keep growing with good CL performances, the more guys will be willing to let their contract expire to come home.

For year one, seems that CPL clubs were unwilling to pay transfer fees. Once clubs will be willing to do that, I expect more quality and experienced guys being bought to come home.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/10/2019 at 3:25 PM, top cheese said:

Newfoundland doesn’t have the capacity to have a stable professional franchise! ...

On the bright side St John's seems to be doing OK in the NBLC:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018–19_NBL_Canada_season#Attendance

and I think that's the same group that have been reported to be interested in CanPL in ownership terms.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

According to this, Jacques Tanguay was approached by a Montreal businessman about a CPL team in Quebec City. He said that whoever comes here needs to not care about balance sheets and be prepare to lose money for 10 years...and also needs to be seriously in for the long term. 

He said gaining Quebec City is a long term project and it will take time to get their loyalty and grow...

He said he offered Joey Saputo his help if he wanted to bring a reserve team to Quebec City...

*I don't think that he and the journalist are aware that CSA wouldn't approve such a move 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Ansem said:

According to this, Jacques Tanguay was approached by a Montreal businessman about a CPL team in Quebec City. He said that whoever comes here needs to not care about balance sheets and be prepare to lose money for 10 years...and also needs to be seriously in for the long term. 

He said gaining Quebec City is a long term project and it will take time to get their loyalty and grow...

He said he offered Joey Saputo his help if he wanted to bring a reserve team to Quebec City...

*I don't think that he and the journalist are aware that CSA wouldn't approve such a move 

 

Ansem my French isn’t the best but does he offer Peps as venue?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Ansem said:

According to this, Jacques Tanguay was approached by a Montreal businessman about a CPL team in Quebec City. He said that whoever comes here needs to not care about balance sheets and be prepare to lose money for 10 years...and also needs to be seriously in for the long term. 

He said gaining Quebec City is a long term project and it will take time to get their loyalty and grow...

He said he offered Joey Saputo his help if he wanted to bring a reserve team to Quebec City...

*I don't think that he and the journalist are aware that CSA wouldn't approve such a move 

 

 

2 minutes ago, BuzzAndSting said:

Ansem my French isn’t the best but does he offer Peps as venue?

“Et selon lui, le stade du Peps serait parfait pour ce type de projet.”

Or is he just saying Peps would be a great place? I’m unfamiliar with the control of the stadium.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, Ansem said:

According to this, Jacques Tanguay was approached by a Montreal businessman about a CPL team in Quebec City. He said that whoever comes here needs to not care about balance sheets and be prepare to lose money for 10 years...and also needs to be seriously in for the long term. 

He said gaining Quebec City is a long term project and it will take time to get their loyalty and grow...

He said he offered Joey Saputo his help if he wanted to bring a reserve team to Quebec City...

*I don't think that he and the journalist are aware that CSA wouldn't approve such a move 

Filosa is a Saputo shill, and his only function in this tweet is to try to keep CPL as far away from Joey as possible. A few months ago he did a whole show on how there was zero possibility of a CPL team anywhere near Montreal. 
 
As I have posted before, this defensiveness we get from Impact does not seem to be very different from the narrow-minded territoriality that exists from Whitecaps. But it is mostly behind the scenes. 
 
At some point (like starting a few months ago), CPL has to move ahead, and just ignore Saputo and the Impact. Who have their reserve side in Ottawa if they want it.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
On 4/18/2019 at 11:28 PM, BuzzAndSting said:

 

“Et selon lui, le stade du Peps serait parfait pour ce type de projet.”

Or is he just saying Peps would be a great place? I’m unfamiliar with the control of the stadium.

My translation: According to him, the Peps stadium would be perfect for this type of project.

Sounds like he's just saying it would be a great place. (i.e. in theory)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

https://www.tsn.ca/radio/montreal-690/bunbury-2021-is-more-realistic-1.1298455

Important points/quotes:

  • "This will happen" - very assuring words
  • There will also be a franchise in Quebec City
  • Plans to Open up a developmental program in Montreal that "will be second to none"
  • Spoke with commissioner Clanachan and said, wants to get things right even if it means 2021. 2020 still on the table
  • Laval is the first location, but others are being assessed 
  • Believes the league will be important, "great start just need to keep the momentum going; not let the "excitement die off"
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Viable stadium solutions can take time when you are dealing with other people's land and/or stadium, so that probably means 2021 at the earliest barring a miracle. Nothing wrong with that. I have never quite understood why Complexe Sportif Claude Robillard isn't a possibility in a Montreal context and Swangard wasn't a possibility for a Fraser valley team, but neither seems to be part of the equation where CanPL is concerned or we would probably already be seeing teams playing there.

5 hours ago, Winnipeg Fury said:

Valour coach Rob Gale, mentioned in an interview today that CPL is talking to 22 different prospective expansion owners.

Which doesn't necessarily contradict there being 18 different communities involved. Hopefully Duane Rollins claiming that Saint John and Pickering are featuring prominently on the radar screen at the moment will end the posts about some markets being kept for a "CanPL2".

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, Ozzie_the_parrot said:

I have never quite understood why Complexe Sportif Claude Robillard isn't a possibility in a Montreal context and Swangard wasn't a possibility for a Fraser valley team, but neither seems to be part of the equation where CanPL is concerned or we would probably already be seeing teams playing there.

Swangard isn't in the Fraser Valley, that's why.

(Okay, addressing what you probably actually meant: the city of Burnaby owns Swangard and doesn't really like pro teams in it. There'd never be Westhills-like upgrades, and the stadium gets enough community and school use outside of the summer that a professional team would have a lot of trouble getting premium kickoff times. Which, in a city owned by the community for the community, is fair enough.)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Lord Bob said:

(Okay, addressing what you probably actually meant: the city of Burnaby owns Swangard and doesn't really like pro teams in it. There'd never be Westhills-like upgrades, and the stadium gets enough community and school use outside of the summer that a professional team would have a lot of trouble getting premium kickoff times. Which, in a city owned by the community for the community, is fair enough.)

I'm not so sure about this. New mayor Mike Hurley likes himself some facilities upgrades. See comments here:

https://www.burnabynow.com/news/the-mayor-s-guarantees-what-burnaby-s-mike-hurley-promises-to-do-in-2019-1.23579980

You're probably stuck with the track at Swangard, but if the land parcel beside the rink location reference above is in play for development, I could see a public/private stadium deal being carved out there. That is a massive chunk of land that I've heard is ready for redevelopment. I actually think that would be a great location. About the same walk from Edmonds as Swangard from Patterson or Joyce.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not speculation, but I think that the three places in need of a team most are Brampton, Mississauga and Laval. I know Ontario would be overloaded but there just seems to be a lot of top quality players coming out of these areas.

I knew Brampton had a lot of players coming out of there, it is actually ridiculous if you look at a list of them. There are probably two full rosters worth of pro players that have come out of Brampton over the past 15 years or so

Link to comment
Share on other sites

36 minutes ago, deschamp86 said:

Not speculation, but I think that the three places in need of a team most are Brampton, Mississauga and Laval. I know Ontario would be overloaded but there just seems to be a lot of top quality players coming out of these areas.

I knew Brampton had a lot of players coming out of there, it is actually ridiculous if you look at a list of them. There are probably two full rosters worth of pro players that have come out of Brampton over the past 15 years or so

Brampton would be a project maybe 10 years down the road. I would say let the league grow and stabilize before aggressive GTA expansion (Sauga and Pickering being the exceptions) occurs. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not sure what to make of this on reddit and what it would do to the expansion process if true:

Will be interesting to see if any new clubs will be added to pro membership at the CSA AGM. In procedural terms this is when any group would normally need to be added for a 2020 launch, and only Saskatoon appears to be far enough along on that where what is happening publicly is concerned.

Edited by Ozzie_the_parrot
Link to comment
Share on other sites

32 minutes ago, Macksam said:

Brampton would be a project maybe 10 years down the road. I would say let the league grow and stabilize before aggressive GTA expansion (Sauga and Pickering being the exceptions) occurs. 

You're probably right. I just can't help but to think about how strong a Brampton team could be using mostly players from the area

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The increase in expansion fee is interesting.  Getting a franchise gets a share in CSB and it sounds like the national sponsorship deals really increases that value.  

A larger expansion fee is going to make it hard to start up in the smaller markets for sure.  There may be a race to 10-12 teams and then a slow down in expansion of that’s true.

I always had a doubt about much more than 12 or 14 teams anyways because the budgets required for a good product will need a good gate and corporate sponsors.  We will have to see.

The best open markets remain  East GVA, Laval, Ottawa Quebec City and one of the Saskatchewan cities.  We seem to hear more of these smaller centres and I think they will have a hard time making the economics of a team work.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share


×
×
  • Create New...