Steven Caldwell A-
The Captain had a solid season that was best demonstrated when he wasn't on the pitch. More so than any other player, TFC depended on Caldwell. Considering he isn't getting any younger, that could be a problem.
Justin Morrow A-
Maybe TFC's most constantly good performer. Should be a core part of the Reds for years to come: Which means he'll likely be exposed in the expansion draft.
Mark Bloom B+
He's exactly the type of value signing that TFC rarely signs. He probably shouldn't be the third highest grade though.
Joe Bendik B
Good shot stopper. Distribution is improving. Is a replacement level keeper, paid an appropriate wage. So, ya: victory!
Jermain Defoe B
He'd be higher if he didn't take a midseason vacation to England. He did perform while he was on the pitch.
Michael Bradley B
Reports of his demise have been greatly exaggerated. Still, needs to be better.
Daniel Lovitz B-
He overachieved and provided a decent wide option off the bench. Absolutely deserves to be considered part of core. Better than many, more expensive options in the midfield.
Gilberto B-
Consistently inconsistent. When he was on though he looked dangerous. When he was off he was way too invisible for a DP.
Jonathan Osorio B-
He didn't score as much in 2014 as in 2013 which led many to suggest he had a weaker season. Close examination suggests otherwise. Rarely playing in his best position, John-O had a solid second year.
Quillan Roberts C+
He probably should be in incomplete, but strong play in Wilmington deserves to be recognized somehow.
Jordan Hamilton C+
See above.
Luke Moore C+
He worked well with Defoe, but not so much without. He's a decent third forward option if he's willing to accept third forward option money.
Nick Hagglund C+
A pleasant surprise, but we shouldn't get too carried away. He faded late in the year as well.
Collen Warner C
A back-up playing a starters role. He has a purpose, but if TFC is to be a contending team it needs an upgrade.
Warren Creavalle C-
Not sure he was ever played in the correct position. Also not sure why TFC traded for him. Was just meh.
Jackson C-
Some will rank him lower, but he has moments. Wildly inconsistent and, although he improved, the rage issues are always right there under the surface. I think he deserves to get a second act in T.O., but CSN understand why others may not.
Doneil Henry C-
The ultimate eye test versus stats test argument. He does things on the pitch -- good things. Those things show up in his performance metrics. He's near the top of MLS in many defensive categories. However, he makes big mistakes that stand out. As a defender those big mistakes can change games. Thus, he gets a tepid passing grade.
Dominic Oduro C-
He showed all the reasons why MLS teams acquire him. And all the reasons why they let him go.
DeRo D
Flashes, but kind of a sad (likely) end.
Bradley Orr D
I was more of a fan than most, but he clearly fell out of favour and wasn't given enough to do to raise his grade.
Andrew Wiedeman D
(Insert "greatest finisher of modern era" joke here)
Ashton Morgan D-
He looked good in his one chance...until a Nick Hagglund error forced him to take a red card. A move to NASL is probably best for everyone.
Kyle Bekker F
If there was such a thing as a designated set-piece taker then Bekker would have a role. As it is, he's demonstrating the perils of drafting four year NCAA players that never learned how to be defensively responsible.
Jeramy Hall F
Apparently he's still under contract. Huh.
Manuel Aparicio Inc.
Chris Konopka Inc.
Chris Mannella Inc.
Others --
TFC Academy A
Undefeated League1 Ontario champions. They are still criticized by some for allegedly ignoring other talent in region. Other than a few kids with Sigma -- Johnny Grant is the most glaring -- I'd love to know who these overlooked kids are...
Ryan Nelsen C-
The style was ugly but he did find a way to have TFC in playoff position early.
Greg Vanney Inc.
Too soon, people.
Tim Bezbatchenko C
The draft was excellent. He did add some useful pieces to a team that was an absolute disaster in 2013. Handling of Nelsen firing is troubling. His grade is in flux until we see how the next few months go.
Tim Leiweke A+
Because he got out.