Jump to content
  • Sign in to follow this  

    Money, Money, Money: The sale of Giovinco and what it means

    Duane Rollins

    Let's start with the obvious. Sebastian Giovinco will be missed. Mostly by Toronto fans, but also by MLS fans in general. The little Italian thrilled fans for four seasons, scoring 73 league goals, many of them of the jaw dropping variety.

    He also won. Three Voyageurs Cups and a Supporters Shield were the appetizer to the ultimate prize. The 2017 MLS Cup championship.

    Dream stuff for long-time TFC fans who lived through a lot of bad football to get to that day.

    He was a Bloody Big Deal.

    And, now he's gone. Not with a bang, but rather a pout. Walking out the door in the middle of the night with an Instagram post that thanked the fans and accused the ownership of cheaping out, no longer caring about the results on the pitch.

    It's a time honoured strategy of players. A Blame the suits move. They're the bad guys that don't care about you little guys in the stands. Make sure to come out for my autograph signing in 2023. Only $50 for a photo!

    Let's be clear. Giovinco has every right to chase the paycheque. I wouldn't turn down $30m and neither would you. But, that's what's happening. Had TFC offered Giovinco the same number he'd be perfectly OK with ownership's commitment to winning. It was their evaluation of his worth that informed his opinion.

    This was always going to happen. This was a player that left Juventus to join TFC, effectively ending his chance at playing internationally again. If he was driven by glory he signs a cheaper deal with a Sassuolo, Chievo or Genoa, rips it up, and has 20 more caps for Italy by now. No one dreams of leaving Juve for Toronto.

    You only leave Juve for two reasons: for money or opportunity to advance your career further. Unless Giovinco thought his agent had misspelled Torino when he sent the offer to him he was coming to Toronto for the money.

    And, he's leaving Toronto for the same reason. It was always going to end this way.

    In terms of the football, it's going to be difficult for Toronto fans to critically evaluate whether it was right for Toronto to let him walk. Should they have matched the Saudi offer and let Giovinco retire as a TFC player?

    Well, he's 32. It's pretty much universally understood that attacking player's peak years are between 23 and 31. The decline after that can be sharp. So, Giovinco is, statistically speaking, past his prime years.

    There are outliers though. Is Giovinco trending upwards?

    His stats over last four years:

    2015 -- age 28, 34 app, 22 goals, 13 assists

    2016 -- age 29, 34 app, 21 goals, 16 assists

    2017 -- age 30, 29 app, 17 goals, 7 assists

    2018 -- age 31, 28 app, 13 goals, 7 assists

    His appearances, goals and assists figure has dropped each of the last two seasons. Doesn't seem to be out of line with statistical norms. If his production drops the same percentage this year as it did between 2017 and 2018 he would end up with between 9 and 10 goals in 2019.

    That's a quality MLS forward, but not a DP and certainly not a $10m a year DP.

    Of course it's also 10 goals TFC is going to need to replace. That's the other side of this move and one that can't be evaluated until it happens. But, by making the move today they have the DP space and money to start that process in the summer, which is generally when MLS teams make their big moves.

    Edited by Duane Rollins

    Sign in to follow this  

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    There are no comments to display.

    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

  • CANMNT_CNL_Toronto_Carousel.jpg

  • Categories

  • Posts

    • Hopefully he can get a look from an MLS club. If not, a CPL club might take a flyer on him.
    • At Leeds he would not be getting the chances and patience he is getting at Lille... he would have been out of the squad after a handful of games with no production. 
    • Two thoughts. Missing that penalty, and it was a miss, absolutely brutal, but that was probably just the universe injecting some justice into the play.  Or David was feeling guilty about the whole thing and subconsciously tanked it.  Don't know.  Same result. U-G-L-Y.  In all caps. And for those who haven't been paying as much attention as I do, EVERYBODY is scoring against Celtic these days.  Least it feels that way.  So...YEEESH.  Also in all caps. I'm not sweating anything yet and neither should he.  The man is an investment and Lille is winning but it might be worth trying a reset sooner rather than later if for no other reason then the pressure to perform may become overwhelming in the New Year and resetting will become that much more difficult.  So maybe a third thought. Start him on the bench.  Give him the last 25-30 minutes.  Dumb it down.  Go out there and run around like an idiot for the final period.   For a couple of matches anyway.  Might clear the fog out of his head and make him seem less a prop for other peoples plays and more of an ingredient in a winning side.  At least to his team mates.  That would be a big step forward.         
    • This next game is huge. If they can beat Tauro we're in for some serious Concacaf fever and they better not find a vaccine for it cuz I got all the symptoms and I like it
    • It's been a rough landing for him, that much is certain.  However Lille know what they signed up for, it's up to the coach to discuss with David what is going well and what is not going well.  What he's comfortable vs what he's not comfortable with.  The coach needs to go back to the videos to see what kind of player he has in his hands.  He needs to look at the spider chart to see and understand what David does well and what he doesn't.  Where did most of his goals come from?  Where was he getting the ball to rack up those assists? etc..... At the moment it looks like a 16 year old bought a Ferrari and can't get it out of 1st gear.  
    • I'm not sure that I've seen Lille attempt any exchanges of short, quick passes anywhere near the opposition box in the 5 games I've watched this season. So, I'm curious how/why you've come to this conclusion.
    • I sort of predicted this would happen. Probably lessens the chances of Forge hosting any games.  
    • I recall being disappointed with David's lack of involvement in the USA games last year.  He was a non factor in those games.   He really doesn't see much of the ball with Lille. You dont see him running at the defence with the ball or making any nice passes.  The only time he seems to get the ball its to pull the trigger, and its not going in.   Anyway, its not easy being a record signing for the first place club in a top 5 league, at striker no less.  He needs our collective support.  
    • I dont think he is done at Lille, its been under ten games and hes their most expensive signing ever.  Its not the best fit in the world for David but he really should have about 4 goals now. Sure he missed the pen but he did draw it so he is doing something right. 
  • Create New...